Climate leads, soil follows: what shapes Europe’s plants

Climate leads, soil follows: what shapes Europe’s plants

Plants can’t get up and walk away from bad conditions. So what decides where each species can grow, and where it can’t?

A new study in Global Ecology and Biogeography, gives a clear answer: mainly climate and soil, with other factors mattering more for some species.

The researchers describe it as one of the first studies to look at this question for all of Europe, both at the scale of the whole continent and within its smaller regions. They pulled together more than 20 million records of where plants were found between 1990 and 2022. These cover 11,824 species, about 60% of Europe’s native plants, from sources including the European Vegetation Archive (EVA) and the Global Biodiversity Information Facility (GBIF).

They trained a machine-learning model on 36 environmental factors, including temperature, rainfall, snow, soil, terrain, water and land use, so it could learn which conditions each species prefers. To check the model had found real patterns, they tested it on regions it hadn’t seen during training.

They then used a technique called SHAP (SHapley Additive exPlanations) to see which factors mattered most, both across Europe and within its natural regions. Finally, they grouped species that respond to the environment in similar ways and checked whether those groups share traits such as lifespan, growth form or habitat.

The answer: climate matters most, especially how much temperatures swing through the year, followed by soil. But that’s not the whole story. The researchers found six distinct groups of plants, each shaped by a different main factor: some by seasons, some by heat and drought, some by snow, others by water, terrain or human land use. A seaside plant like sea arrowgrass, for instance, depends mostly on water conditions. Rare species turned out to depend less on climate than common ones, which means focusing on climate alone could leave them overlooked.

Location and scale matter too. Climate has more influence in southern and western Europe, while soil counts for more in the north and east. Within individual regions, soil, water and land use become more important than they are across the continent as a whole.

The authors caution that their results describe where plants grow today, not where they will move as the climate changes. Many species still haven’t spread back into all the areas that would suit them since the last ice age. Accounting for that history, they say, is the next step toward better predictions of how Europe’s flora will respond to a changing world.

Read the full article here.